Skip to content
  1. Home
  2. Blog
  3. Is an SEO agency worth it?
AI search5 November 2026·8 min read

Is it worth hiring an SEO agency in 2026, now that AI answers the search?

An SEO agency is worth it when your business wins customers through search and nobody on your team can handle the technical side, the content and the mentions you need on other sites. You do not need one if you are a small local business, if you cannot fund the work for several months, or if the agency promises results nobody controls.

Is a SEO agency worth it? cover with the Google logo and an AI assistant answer

Key takeaways

  • When an AI summary appeared, Google users clicked a result on 8% of visits, against 15% without one, according to Pew Research Center (March 2025).
  • Google says optimising for its AI search is "still SEO". You do not need a separate agency for AI, but you do need one that also works beyond your own site.
  • For a small local business, Google considers that much of the work can be done in-house.
  • Nobody can guarantee a ranking on Google or a mention in ChatGPT. If an agency promises either, walk away.

Is it worth hiring an SEO agency in 2026?

Yes, if your customers look for you on Google or in AI assistants and nobody on your team covers technical work, content and outside mentions. No, if you are a small local business that can handle the basics, if you cannot fund several months of work before seeing an effect, or if the agency promises guaranteed rankings or appearances.

AI has not made SEO agencies pointless. It has changed what they need to do. Informational searches send fewer clicks, and part of the buying decision now happens inside the assistant's answer. That is why useful SEO work no longer stops at your own website.

Data checked on 5 November 2026. The click figures come from studies published in 2025, and the hiring advice comes from Google's own documentation for people who hire SEO help.

What has AI changed in search?

The number of people who click has changed. Pew Research Center looked at the Google searches of 900 US adults during March 2025. When an AI summary appeared, they clicked a result on 8% of visits, against 15% when there was no summary. Clicks on a link inside the summary itself stayed at 1%.

Seer Interactive found something similar with data from 42 organisations and 3,119 informational queries. In its study published on 4 November 2025, organic CTR for those queries with an AI Overview fell from 1.76% in June 2024 to 0.61% in September 2025.

The same study found that brands cited in the AI Overview had a higher organic CTR than brands that were not: 0.70% against 0.52%. The authors say they cannot prove that being cited causes the clicks. Brands with more authority may simply be cited more often and clicked more often.

The foundations have not changed. Google's guide to generative AI search, published in May 2026, says that optimising for it is "still SEO". It does not ask for special files or markup either. Our guide to SEO for AI search goes into more detail.

For a European business there is one more layer. Ask the assistants the same question in each language you sell in. The sources they cite can differ from one market to another, so mentions in one country's press and directories do not necessarily carry over to the rest.

When an SEO agency is worth it

An SEO agency pays off when search already drives sales, or could, and the work needs more skills than you have in-house. These are the situations where we see it most clearly:

  • You sell services, products or software that people research before buying, and much of that research starts on Google or in an assistant.
  • You are about to rebuild your site or launch a new one. Google says that is a good time to bring in help, and the earlier the better. What to demand in that case is in our website migration SEO guide.
  • Your competitors appear in the comparisons and lists that assistants cite, and you do not.
  • Someone writes for you, but nobody checks crawling, structured data, migrations or bot blocking on the server.
  • You can give the agency one person on your side who validates content and knows the product.

That last condition is often forgotten. An agency without access to someone who knows the business ends up writing generic pages, which add nothing that other pages do not already say, for a buyer or for an assistant. The work goes better as a collaboration than as a closed brief.

When is an SEO agency not worth it?

It is not worth it if your demand does not come through search, or if you can do the basics yourself. Google says so on its page "Do you need an SEO?". A small local business can do much of the work on its own, starting with Google's starter guide.

For a neighbourhood business, a complete and well-kept Google Business Profile usually does more than a monthly retainer. We explain how in our guide to local SEO on Google Maps.

It is not worth it either if you cannot keep the work going. Content and outside mentions build up over time, and stopping after two months usually leaves the money spent and the job half done. If the fee forces you to decide month by month, start with a one-off audit and apply the changes yourself.

And it is not worth it with just any agency. If the pitch is about guaranteed rankings, article volume or "link packages", the fault lies with the supplier and not with SEO.

Agency, freelancer, in-house team or doing it yourself

The real question is rarely agency or no agency. It is which mix fits your size. This table sums up when each option fits and what it tends to leave uncovered.

OptionFits whenWhat it tends to leave out
Doing it yourselfLocal business, few pages and time to learnTechnical diagnosis and press mentions
FreelancerYou need one specialism, such as technical SEO or contentWhatever that person does not cover, and continuity if they leave
In-house teamSearch drives a lot of revenue and there is a full-time workloadSkills not worth hiring for, such as development or media relations
AgencyYou need technical work, content and mentions at once, without building a teamProduct knowledge, unless someone on your side brings it

Many companies combine options. A common setup is an in-house team that writes and an agency that handles the technical work and outside mentions. What fails is splitting the work without anyone owning the result.

What should an SEO agency do about AI?

An SEO agency in 2026 should cover four fronts. Making sure Google's and the assistants' crawlers can read your site. Making your pages answer a buyer's questions early and with data. Getting you named by the outside sources that assistants cite. And measuring in business terms and AI presence, not just rankings.

When an assistant recommends suppliers, it often cites third-party pages, such as comparisons, directories and media. An agency that only touches your site leaves out that part of what the buyer reads. That work looks more like digital PR than like buying links.

Google suggests concrete questions for choosing. Ask the agency to show previous work and to follow Google's guidelines. Ask what results it expects, in what timeframe and how it will measure success. And ask it to share every change it makes to your site, with the reason.

We would add one more question for 2026. Ask what they will check in ChatGPT, Gemini or AI Overviews, how often and with which questions. They do not have to hand over their full method, but the measurement should exist and be repeatable.

Red flags when hiring an SEO agency

The clearest red flag is a promise nobody can keep. Google puts it plainly on its page for people hiring help: no one can guarantee a number one ranking. The same applies to AI, because answers change with each question and each user.

  • Guaranteed rankings, or guaranteed appearances in ChatGPT or AI Overviews by a fixed date.
  • Claims of a special relationship with Google or of tools "approved" by Google. Google's AI guide says no third-party tool has access to its ranking or AI systems.
  • Asking for write access to Search Console for an audit. Read access is enough to review.
  • Asking you to link to the agency from your site. Google says you should never have to.
  • Not explaining what they change or why. Google reminds you that you are responsible for what any company you hire does.

If the approach comes from an agency you do not know, in an email you did not ask for, Google treats that as a reason for caution too. Good agencies usually arrive through a referral or because you found them.

How much does an SEO agency cost, and when will you notice?

Published prices vary widely and few explain what is included. We go through them, with sources, in how much a digital marketing agency costs per month. Our monthly SEO retainer starts at €1,400 a month before VAT, and we say so up front so you can rule us out early if it does not fit.

On timing, Google does not give a figure and recommends asking. Be wary of anyone who sets one before looking at your site. What is reasonable is a written schedule showing what is delivered each month and which indicator will be reviewed.

Technical fixes can show within weeks, because crawlers come back quickly. Content and mentions take longer to build up. Agree from the start what will be measured at month three and what at month six.

Where to start before hiring

Before asking for quotes, rule out the obvious. Run your site through our free analyser to see whether AI crawlers can get in and whether your content arrives in the HTML. If something is blocked, fixing it is cheap and changes what you need from an agency.

Then put Google's questions, plus the AI one, to two or three agencies and compare the written answers. If you want one of them to be us, the service is SEO for AI search, which joins classic SEO with the work on assistants.

Frequently asked questions

Will AI replace SEO agencies?

AI automates tasks such as drafting copy or grouping keywords, but it does not decide which sources mention you or fix a block on your server. Google still treats optimising for its AI search as SEO, so the work exists. The mix changes: fewer articles, more technical work, data and mentions.

Do I need one agency for SEO and another for GEO?

No. Google says optimising for its AI search is still SEO, and the foundations are the same. What matters is that your SEO agency also works on outside sources and measures your presence in assistants, because SEO focused only on your own site does not cover that part.

Can an agency guarantee that I will appear in ChatGPT?

No. Neither OpenAI nor Google publishes exactly how they choose whom to name, and answers change with each question and each user. An agency can remove blocks, improve your pages and work on the sources assistants cite, but it cannot promise an appearance. More in how to get ChatGPT to recommend your business.

What access should I give an SEO agency?

For an audit, read access to Search Console and analytics is enough. If the agency will later change your site, it should use its own user account and explain every change. Google advises against granting write access for an audit and reminds you that you are responsible for what anyone you hire does.

JB
Juan Berges

Juan Berges is the CEO of The Baller Company and writes about digital advertising, SEO, AI search and the latest changes at Google, Meta, LinkedIn and TikTok.

Before you hire

Can buyers find you on Google and in AI answers?

We check whether Google's and the assistants' crawlers can read your site, which sources they cite in your sector and what work would make sense for you.